Chocolate Frog Cards

Sixty-eight wizards and witches on collectible cards, sold in packs by a frog-shaped confectionery subsidiary that has never once explained where the portraits come from. Collect them, crumble the spares into dust, craft the gaps shut, and duel for gold with five cards at a time, either on autopilot or one square at a time.

The Collection

There are sixty-eight cards, spread across five rarities: Common, Uncommon, Rare, Epic, and Legendary. Your binder shows every card in the album, the ones you own, how many copies you keep, and the ones still missing. You keep up to three copies of a card. The fourth copy and everything after it crumbles into dust, because there is a limit to how many Merlins one desk can hold.

Use the binder's name search, Collection filter and Rarity filter to find a main-set card. Reset filters shows the full main set again.

The album also grows. About four times a year a wave of twelve new cards joins the main set on a published date; until that date the binder says so plainly (Coming, with the day), and no pack, pool, or board counts a card early. The frog had to be talked into announcing anything in advance, and has taken to it with suspicious enthusiasm.

Rarity is always written out on the card. Nothing important is communicated by glow alone, and the artwork is decoration; the text next to it is the card.

The Faculty

Eighteen members of the teaching staff have joined the album, filed under whatever they teach or, in a few cases, whatever they survived. Three are Common: Gilderoy Lockhart, Professor Binns, and Quirinus Quirrell. The frog insists their rarity is a comment on the lessons and not on the careers, and has stopped taking questions. Ten are Uncommon: Madam Hooch, Professor Sinistra, Professor Vector, Professor Babbling, Charity Burbage, Sybill Trelawney, Professor Grubbly-Plank, Pomona Sprout, Rubeus Hagrid, and Horace Slughorn. Five are Rare: Remus Lupin, Filius Flitwick, Alastor Moody, Minerva McGonagall, and Severus Snape. Albus Dumbledore was already here as an Epic and remains the only professor above Rare, which the staff room regards as correct.

Faculty cards play by the same rules as everyone else. A professor's power sits inside the range for the professor's rarity, a Rare professor is no stronger than the strongest Rare that was already in the album, and a House still decides only where a card is strong, never how strong. The frog adds, unprompted, that no professor outranks Merlin.

The published odds did not change: Common 60%, Uncommon 25%, Rare 10%, Epic 4%, Legendary 1%. What changed is the crowd. A Rare is still 10% of draws, but there are now ten of them to share it, so any one Rare turns up about half as often as it used to, and the same is true of the Uncommons. The Rare professors can be crafted for 100 dust like any other Rare, which is the frog's way of saying it noticed.

Packs and Published Odds

Three ways to buy cards, and the frog publishes the odds because the Ministry made it:

  • Bean Pack: 150 Bertie Botts Every Flavor Beans for 5 cards.
  • 3-Card Pack: 100 Donator Points for 3 cards.
  • 8-Card Pack: 250 Donator Points for 8 cards, at least one of them Rare or better, guaranteed.

Each card drawn rolls the same ladder: Common 60%, Uncommon 25%, Rare 10%, Epic 4%, Legendary 1%. The rolls are honest, the ladder is the live one, and the shop prints it every day in case the frog forgets.

On top of the ladder, each card can also come up a Limited Edition card while a monthly edition is live, the Edition Pack raises those odds for a price, and any card can arrive as a foil. Those mechanics have their own page: Chocolate Frog Limited Editions.

Card spending is capped at 2,000 Donator Points per day across every card product, including the featured pulls below. The castle considers this a courtesy.

Every product has one button that says what it is and what it costs, such as "Buy 3-Card Pack (100 Donator Points)". Press it and a small window shows the pack, the price, what you have now and what you will have after, and how much of today's cap is left. One more press on Buy and the pack opens right there in the window, without the page going anywhere. If you are short of beans or points, or the purchase would pass the cap, the button is grayed out and says by how much ("You need 150 beans; you have 1"), which saves everyone the indignity of a refusal.

The Legendary Guarantee

At least one Legendary card arrives every 30 packs. The counter runs across every kind of pack, including the contest finds below, and a forced Legendary resets it. The frog calls this destiny. The ledger calls it a counter. Both are correct, which is the most either has ever managed.

Featured Pulls

Two products aim at a rotating window of five featured cards:

  • Targeted Pull: 300 Donator Points, one card, a 50% chance of the featured card.
  • Master Pull: 800 Donator Points, one card, a 90% chance of the featured card.

When the roll misses the featured card, you get one of the other four featured cards instead. Featured pulls are per purchase, they do not interact with the Legendary guarantee, and the guarantee does not count them. You pays your points and the frog rolls its dice.

Wizard Card Contest

The Wizard Card Contest counts finds; your binder keeps cards. Enter the contest in the village market for 2 gems, then find cards while playing and turn in your tally for contest points. George Weasley supplies a perception potion. The consent form is shorter than the potion's ingredient list.

Each accepted find also draws one free Chocolate Frog card at the normal pack odds. It goes into your binder immediately, counts toward the Legendary guarantee and follows the three-copy shelf and dust rules. Turning in the tally never takes cards from your binder. Card Duels and Your Rival are separate activities.

A find notice names both results: the contest find and the binder card or dust. If the page redirects, the notice follows you to the next game page.

  • Finds per day: typically 9 to 12, re-rolled each new day. They appear as you move between pages, never on the same page twice in a row, and only on pages you can actually see.
  • The tally: up to 5 finds wait on your tally at once (the Contest Finds stat in your character panel shows it). A find that turns up with the tally full is announced, regretted, and wasted: no card, no allowance spent.
  • Turning in: hand the tally in at the Wizard Card Contest in the village market. One find is one hunt point, and the board ranks everyone by contest points. Cards already in your binder stay there either way.

The prize pool is 2 gems per entrant. Second place receives 20% and third place 10%, rounded to whole gems; first place receives the remainder, normally 70%. The displayed prizes use the same split as the payout.

A contest runs 4 to 28 days, then resets: prizes go to the top three, scores are wiped, and you re-enter for 2 gems. Changing your mind is allowed and not refunded. Withdrawing leaves the 2 gems in the pot, forfeits your tally and contest points, stops the frogs finding you, and bars you from rejoining until the next contest begins. The cards you already found are yours to keep, since the binder was never part of the wager.

Dust and Crafting

Copies past the third become dust: 1 dust for a Common, 2 for an Uncommon, 5 for a Rare, 10 for an Epic, and 25 for a Legendary. Dust buys the cards the packs would not:

  • 25 dust: one Common card of your choice.
  • 50 dust: one Uncommon card of your choice.
  • 100 dust: one Rare card of your choice.

The Craft button sits on the missing card in your binder and opens the same small window: the card, the dust it costs, your dust before and after. Short of dust, the button says how much you have instead of pretending.

Epic and Legendary cards cannot be crafted. The top of the album answers only to packs, featured pulls, and the guarantee, which the frog describes as tradition.

Two cards also arrive without a purchase. Capturing one of the six Forest residents who has a card of their own (Snape, Binns, and the four Founders) hands you that card, and beating a professor in the training yard hands you that professor's card, one of the fourteen levels from Lockhart to Dumbledore. Both follow the shelf rule above, so a card you already own becomes a spare copy, or dust past the third. Crafting stays the way to fill a gap you have not met yet.

Card Duels

The frog offers two ways to settle a grudge over gold. They share one ledger, one stack of dust, and the same daily allowance, and they disagree about almost everything else.

  • Quick Duel plays itself. You pick the cards, and the frog does the rest.
  • Card Duel does not. You pick the cards and the squares, one move at a time, and nobody can be blamed for the result except you.

Put plainly, Quick Duel is luck and Card Duel is skill. Both count against the same three duels a day (for a student challenge, the sender pays), with one exception: practice games against First-Year Freddy on the mat are free, pay nothing, and count against nothing.

Card Duel: The Mat

The mat is a three-by-three grid of nine squares. You hold five cards, your opponent holds five, and you take turns placing one card on any empty square. Whoever opens is decided by the frog. Nine squares take nine cards, so whoever opens places five and the other side places four and keeps one in hand.

Every card has four edges: top, right, bottom, and left, each a number from 1 to 10. Stronger cards, which is to say rarer ones, have higher edges overall. A card's House decides how its strength is spread across the edges (some are lopsided, some even), but never how much strength there is: the edges of a card add up to what its power says they should. Fairness, in the frog's view, is an arrangement of numbers.

When you place a card, it argues with each opposing card it touches. The two facing edges are compared, and if yours is strictly higher, the opposing card turns over and becomes yours. A tie changes nothing. Turned cards do not turn their own neighbors, so there are no chain reactions, only a lot of quiet local resentment.

Two squares on the mat carry a House banner, picked when the game starts and printed on the board. A card of that House placed on a banner square gets +1 on every edge (to a maximum of 10). This applies to both sides, and the board shows the adjusted edges so you can check the arithmetic yourself. Practice games have no banners.

When the mat is full, your score is the squares you own plus the cards still in your hand. The total is always ten, so the winner has six or more, and five-five is a draw.

Your hand is five cards from your binder, no repeats, and at most one of them Epic or Legendary. The opponents' hands follow the same rule, because the frog applies its regulations evenly and without looking up. You choose it once, under "Your hand" on the Duels tab, and it stays chosen for every duel until you change it. Until you choose, the frog deals you your five strongest, which is also what most people would have chosen after a great deal of thought.

The Duels tab shows one thing at a time. Before a game it shows your hand, the opponents and any challenges. Once a game starts, the tab becomes that game: the mat, your hand, the score and whose move it is, and nothing you could change mid-duel. When the game ends you get a result panel: who won, the gold or dust that moved, a button to play the same opponent again with the same hand, and New duel, which takes you back to the start. The same panel greets a finished game you reopen from the recent-games list with its "Show the final board" link; reopening never plays anything, and the rematch button waits for you to press it. Every move, purchase and change happens in place, so the page stays where you left it instead of flinging you back to the top.

Each card wears its four edge numbers on its four sides, top number on top, so the arithmetic is printed exactly where the argument happens. The name sits on the card's plaque and the colored gem beside it is the rarity: silver for Common, green for Uncommon, blue for Rare, violet for Epic, and flame red for Legendary. The binder repeats the color on each cell, as a thin line along its top edge and on the name and rarity tag, and only Legendary cells glow, because somebody had to. The word is written out in every cell as well, since a color is a poor witness on its own.

A turn has two steps, the way you would play at a real table. First put a card down: drag it from your hand onto an empty square, or tap the card and then the square. It sits there as your pending move, and every opposing card it would turn is marked "Turns". Nothing has been sent. Then play it: tap the card again (it says Play) or press Play card.

Until you play, the mat is negotiable. Drag the pending card to another square, or back to your hand. Drop a different card from your hand on top of it and the two swap places. Drag hand cards onto each other to put your hand in whatever order helps you think. Squares already played are permanent, and dropping a card on one earns a short remark from the Frog, who has opinions about crowding.

After each turn the board replays the last two placements: the opponent takes a moment to think (a courtesy; it has already decided), the cards land, the ones that changed sides flip over, and turning two or more at once gets announced, because the Frog believes in recognition. A finished game ends with the result panel, against a student as well as against the castle (the student version is described below).

The keyboard and screen-reader route is the same two steps without the dragging: pick a card and a square from the two lists, hear what the move would turn, then press Play card. Nothing is played until you say so. With reduced motion turned on, the replays and flips are skipped and the board shows how things stand.

Card Duel: The Opponents

Four opponents, easiest first. Stakes leave your purse when the game starts. A win pays the amount below plus dust, which is added to your binder.

  • First-Year Freddy (Practice): costs nothing, pays nothing, and may be played as often as you like. He plays wherever there is room. If you do not own five cards yet, he lends you a borrowed hand, which you return afterwards with no paperwork. This is the only tier with a loan desk.
  • Groundskeeper Graw: stake 200 gold. A win pays 400 gold and 5 dust. He takes whichever square turns the most cards right now and never once thinks about your reply.
  • Professor Pince: stake 1,000 gold. A win pays 2,500 gold and 15 dust. She checks your best reply before she commits, which is one more thought than most people manage.
  • The Headmaster's Portrait: stake 3,000 gold. A win pays 9,000 gold and 40 dust. He thinks three moves ahead, and in the last five squares, all of them. He has had several centuries to practice.

During Dueling Club Night (see the Player vs Player page) Professor Flitwick joins the opponents. He is free, unlimited and uses none of your daily duels; the first win against him each night earns bonus House Points.

The terms printed when you start are the terms you play under. A draw hands your stake straight back and awards no dust. A loss keeps the stake, as losses do. Forfeiting an unfinished game is a loss with extra steps: the stake stays with the house, which is the one thing the frog and the Ministry agree on.

Each staked game (Graw, Pince, or the Portrait) uses one of your three duels a day, the same three that Quick Duel draws from. Practice does not touch the allowance. Every move still works as a plain form with a button, every placement and capture is also written out as a line of text, and the result announces itself.

Card Duel: Against Other Students

The mat also seats two students, which is where the frog's regulations become interesting, because the opponent can hold a grudge. On the Duels tab, type a student's name, set a stake from 100 to 10,000 gold (the form suggests 500), and send the challenge. Your stake leaves your purse at once and waits in escrow, which is a drawer the frog keeps for exactly this.

  • Answering: the student has 24 hours. They accept with their own hand and match your stake. Or they decline, and your stake comes straight home. If they say nothing for 24 hours, the challenge lapses and your stake comes home anyway. Silence counts as a polite no.
  • Playing: the board is the same mat, the same edges, the same banners. Each turn has 24 hours on the clock. Several games can run at once, and each shows its deadline and whose move it is, with "Play your move" (or "Open the board" while you wait) to open that game. While you watch a game that is waiting on the other student, their move appears on your mat by itself a few seconds after they make it, flips and all.
  • The pot: twice the stake, less the castle's tenth (10%). On a 1,000 gold stake the pot is 1,800, so the winner nets 800 and the loser is out 1,000. A draw, five squares each, refunds both stakes in full and the castle takes nothing, having nothing to take a tenth of.
  • Getting paid: gold you win, or get back, while you were away from the mat does not teleport into your purse. It waits at the castle's front desk and is handed over the next time you load any page in the castle, which in practice means about now. The owl that tells you the result already names the amount, and a line above the tabs marks the arrival. Gold for the player who is actually at the mat lands at once. The frog has asked everyone to regard the delay as filing, not loss.
  • Missing a turn: if 24 hours pass on your move, you forfeit, and the whole pot goes to the player who was waiting. The deadline shown on a challenge or a turn is in your own time zone (your Preferences setting, or your device's clock if you have not set one), so "answer by 9:12pm" means 9:12pm where you are. The clock settles the game, not a late move. The settling is a filing process rather than an event: until the castle's sweep records the result, the game sits in your list read-only, marked "the castle is settling it", with the gold still safe in escrow. Visiting the Duels tab hurries the sweep along; so does waiting. In the rare case a stored game cannot be read at all, it is voided instead and both stakes come home, the frog declining to guess.
  • The ending: a finished board, whether you just finished it or reopened it later, carries a result panel. It says who won and how (the board filled up, someone resigned, or someone's 24 hours ran out), where the gold went (the pot less the castle's tenth, or both stakes home on a draw), and offers two buttons: "Challenge [opponent] again" and "Back to duels". The first opens the Duels tab with the opponent and the old stake already typed into the challenge form and your saved hand ready to play. It sends nothing; the frog has met people who rematch in anger and would like one deliberate click between the feeling and the stake. Games that ended before the panel learned to say how simply say the player resigned or ran out of time, since the record did not keep the difference.
  • Resigning: you may resign while your turn is still running. The pot goes to your opponent. Once the deadline has passed, a resignation is refused, because the clock has already decided who owes whom.

The limits are few but firm. You and a given student may have only one waiting challenge between you at a time, in either direction, so nobody can challenge twice by double-clicking. Nobody may have more than ten Card Duels open at once, and if either of you is at the limit, the frog says so and sends nothing. A duel still being settled counts as open until the sweep has filed it, its gold still sitting in the drawer. You cannot challenge yourself, which the frog considered and decided against.

The daily allowance applies to the person who sends the challenge. Each challenge uses one of your three duels a day, the same three Quick Duel and the staked NPC games draw from, and a declined or lapsed challenge does not give the slot back. Accepting a challenge costs the defender nothing against their three. Stakes are gold only. No Donator Points and no dust change hands, so two accounts passing gold back and forth lose a tenth of it on every lap.

Owls are kept to a minimum, in-game only, never as email: one for a new challenge, one to each player when a game ends (with the result and any gold), and one for a missed turn, a lapse or a decline. Turns ring the bell instead. A "your move" owl goes out only if you have been away from the castle for half an hour or more, and only one at a time per game, so a long game does not bury your owl post. If a game is waiting on you, the bell rings and keeps ringing until you act or the clock runs out (the Notifications page has the bell's side of this). The Duels tab also lists your five most recent finished games with students, each with a "Show the final board" link, read-only, for reviewing exactly where it went wrong. Your five most recent games on the mat against the castle have the same link.

The Collector in the Forest

Somewhere between the third oak and the sixth, a gentleman named Barnaby Thrupp waits with a clipboard. He is an itinerant collector, officially unlicensed, and he has never once been refused by a tree. When you search the Forbidden Forest he may step out as one of the Forest's specials, and when he does, you are going to play one Card Duel. The bylaw requiring this is his own, and he is proud of it.

  • How often: never more than once per game day, and never while a mat game of yours is unfinished, since he refuses to interrupt. How likely he is depends on how much Card Duel you have already played. If you have never played a Card Duel, he holds a 20% share of the Forest's specials. If you have played one to four games (against students or on the mat), that drops to 8%. Five or more, and it is 2%, on the theory that you know where the mat is. The Forest only produces a special on some searches, so even a newcomer will not be ambushed on every one.
  • The wager: optional, and asked twice. Mr. Thrupp offers a stake of 20 gold per level of yours, never fewer than 10 gold, never more than 300, and never more than you are carrying. Say no and he will mock you, politely, and ask again. Say no a second time and the game is played for nothing but pride. If your purse is under 10 gold, he skips the asking and plays you for the cards.
  • The money: a wager leaves your purse when you sit down and waits in escrow, the same drawer the frog uses for every other game. A win returns it doubled (your stake back, plus the same again from his side). A draw returns it untouched. A loss, or forfeiting the game, keeps it. A free game moves no gold at all.
  • The prize: win, with a wager or without, and he hands over one card drawn from the same stock and the same published odds as a shop pack. A first copy goes in your binder with its badge. A fourth copy or later converts to dust, as always. A draw or a loss earns no card, only a remark. This prize does not touch the legendary guarantee counter, because a card from a stranger in a forest is not, administratively, a pack.
  • Your hand: your best five cards, no repeats, at most one Epic or Legendary. If you do not have five usable cards yet, he lends you five commons for this game only. They go back in his satchel afterwards, and nothing but the prize ever enters your binder.
  • The opponent: Mr. Thrupp moves at random and owns a modest deck of commons and uncommons. He does not think about your reply, or about anything else. The game itself is the ordinary mat: same grid, same edges, same banners.

The game appears on the Duels tab as soon as you accept, and a Return to the Forest link sits in the left-hand menu until you are finished. His game does not use up any of your three duels a day. If you wander off with it unfinished, it waits on the mat until you play it out or forfeit, and it counts as a Card Duel you have played, so he will notice you are less of a newcomer than you were.

Quick Duel

Quick Duel plays your hand, the same five chosen for Card Duels. Open the Quick Duel section on the Duels tab and pick an opponent: one of the house mats with fixed stakes, or another student for a stake between 100 and 10,000 gold. Challenges to other students come in both flavors; this section covers the Quick one, and the tactical one has its own section below.

A duel is best of five rounds. Each round pits your next card against theirs. A card's power is its printed power, plus 5 points per rarity tier, plus a roll of 0 to 20. Higher power takes the round; most rounds takes the match. The duel is fully deterministic, sealed at challenge time, so the same decks and the same duel always replay the same result. Nobody can reroll a loss, including the frog.

Challenges are asynchronous. Your stake leaves your purse when you challenge and sits in escrow. If they accept, their stake joins it, the duel resolves on the spot, and the winner takes the pot minus the castle's tenth (10%). If they decline, or 24 hours pass with no answer, your stake walks back to your vault untouched. You may start three duels a day; accepting one does not count against anybody's three.

Every round renders as a text line with both cards and their powers, and the full result announces itself, because a duel you cannot read is just a gold transfer with confetti.

Collection Sets

Two Chocolate Frog sets join the Collection Sets board: The Four Founders (Godric, Rowena, Helga, and Salazar, carded) and Frog Legends (Merlin, Morgana, Dumbledore, and Flamel). Completing a set pays its bonus like any other set. The founders have been in the same castle for a thousand years; now they are in your binder too, which everyone agrees is different.

The Bestiary

The album has a second volume, shelved in your binder below the first. It holds one card for each creature of the Forest that has a portrait of its own, which comes to just under six hundred. These are not among the sixty-eight, they do not count toward the sixty-eight, and the binder keeps a separate tally ("Bestiary: 12 of 594 creatures") so neither number has to apologize to the other.

There is exactly one way in. Capture the creature with Newt Scamander's suitcase and its card slides out of the lining, no crafting required. The Forest Reserve and the suitcase page both say so, in case the lining is not enough of a hint. The suitcase is sold at the Forest Reserve (under Curiosities in the Forest menu), a capture attempt needs Magizoologist rank 1, and the attempt appears after a win in the Forest or in an expansion pack such as the Haunted Bakery, whose residents have cards of their own. Capturing is a roll, not a promise, and the creature declines to remember you tried. Bestiary cards are never in packs, featured pulls, or the contest, they cannot be crafted, and the published pack odds are the same as before. A creature you have not captured shows as a dark silhouette with its name and rarity underneath, because the Forest likes to be seen to have a waiting list.

Rarity follows the creature's level: levels 1 to 5 are Common, 6 to 9 Uncommon, 10 to 13 Rare, 14 to 16 Epic, and level 17 Legendary. Creatures that share one portrait share one card, so Bellatrix's Wraith, who turns up at fifteen different levels, gets a single card, and the highest level decides its rarity. A second capture that lands on a card you already hold adds nothing. The Bestiary records species, not enthusiasm. Creatures named by students, and the few without a portrait of their own, have no card.

Bestiary cards are for collecting. They carry no duel power, never appear in a hand, and are not part of Card Collectors or the profile's card count. If you captured creatures before the Bestiary existed, their cards are filed the next time you open your binder, your suitcase, or the capture page, with a one-line note from Newt saying how many. The filing is done once per card, never makes a second copy, and costs nothing, which is more than can be said for most filing.

Where It Lives

Two boards in the Hall of Fame and on the public Hogwarts Champions page keep score: Card Collectors ranks distinct Chocolate Frog cards owned from the main sixty-eight, Bestiary cards excluded (ties go to legendaries, then to whoever got there first), and Card Duel Wins ranks victories over other students, with games played and win rate alongside. Draws, voids, and matches against the Headmaster's Portrait do not count, which the Portrait has taken personally.

The binder, the shop, and the dueling mat share one page, tabbed, reachable from the village square and, as Chocolate Frog Card Packs, from the Prefect's Lounge (which opens straight onto the Shop tab). Tabs answer the arrow keys, packs announce what they dealt, and the frog's portrait is a decorative image with opinions, not information.

Your collection also sits on your profile page, just after Character Details and before Adventures & Accolades, with a count of how many of the catalog you have found. A row of your own picks leads it: up to three cards you pinned from the binder's detail sheets (five for VIP members). View all opens any others. It is shown to visitors, on the theory that a card nobody sees is merely cardboard with ambitions. Visitors can fold the grid away with Hide cards. If you would rather keep the whole tally to yourself, the button on your own profile hides it from visitors entirely, heading and all.

Somewhere in the binder there is a set called The Flock. Every card in it is the same sheep. This has not stopped anyone from collecting all twelve.